How to Post a Custom Conflict

If you are using automatic matching, you can generate conflicts automatically with Paper Matching Setup. Sometimes Program Chairs additionally want to create custom conflicts between certain users and certain papers. This can be done by posting an edge to the conflict edge invitation for your venue.

1. If you have not done so, you will need to install and instantiate the openreview-py client.

2. Determine the conflict invitation you will be using. If you are creating a custom conflict edge for a reviewer, it would be <your_venue_id>/Reviewers/-/Conflict. If it is for an Area Chair, it would be <your_venue_id>/Area_Chairs/-/Conflict.

venue_group = client_v2.get_group(venue_id)
invitation = venue_group.content['reviewers_conflict_id']['value]
# For ACs: venue_group.content['area_chairs_conflict_id']['value]
# For SACs: venue_group.content['senior_area_chairs_conflict_id']['value]

1. Set a variable 'tail' to the user you are generating the conflict for. Set a variable 'head' to the ID of the submission you want to create the conflict for. For example:

tail = "~User_One1"
head = "ggVj9Mmq2-a"

1. Set the readers of this conflict. In general, this should include the tail of the edge and anyone who might be making assignments for this group, such as Area Chairs or Senior Area Chairs.

Confirm who the readers should be by going to: openreview.net/invitation/edit?id=<conflict_invitation> and checking the readers.

readers = [
    "~User_One1", 
    "your_venue_id",
    "<your_venue_id>/Area_Chairs"
]

1. Optionally set a label for your custom conflicts. This can help you query and retrieve them later.

label = "Custom Conflict"

1. Finally, create and post an edge with a weight of -1 between the user and the paper. This will make the conflict a hard constraint.

client_v2.post_edge(openreview.api.Edge(
   invitation = invitation,
   label = label, 
   weight = -1, 
   head = head, 
   tail = tail,
   signatures = [
    "<your_venue_id>"
   ],
   readers = [
    "<your_venue_id>"
   ],
   writers = [
    "<your_venue_id>"
]))

1. If you're posting a lot of conflicts, you can build a list of Edges and post them all at once with post_bulk_edges.

openreview.tools.post_bulk_edges(client=client_v2, edges=[list of conflict Edges])