OpenReview
  • Overview
    • OpenReview Documentation
  • Reports
    • Conferences
      • OpenReview NeurIPS 2021 Summary Report
      • OpenReview ECCV 2020 Summary Report
  • Getting Started
    • Frequently Asked Questions
      • I accidentally withdrew a submission, what do I do?
      • How do I add a Program Chair to my venue?
      • When will I be able to withdraw my submission?
      • I want to delete my withdrawn or desk-rejected paper, what do I do?
      • An author of a submission cannot access their own paper, what is the problem?
      • What should I do if I find a vulnerability in OpenReview?
      • How can I report a bug or request a feature?
      • What is the difference between due date (duedate) and expiration date (expdate)?
      • Will Reviewers be notified of their Assignments?
      • What is the max file size for uploads?
      • Why are the "rating" and "confidence" fields in my PC Console wrong?
      • What should I do if my question is not answered here?
      • My Profile is "Limited". What does that mean?
      • What field types are supported in the forms?
      • How do I recruit reviewers?
      • How do I obtain a letter of proof for my services as a reviewer?
      • How do I complete my tasks?
      • Can I automatically transfer my Expertise Selection to another venue?
      • Why does it take two weeks to moderate my profile?
      • What do the different 'status' values mean in the message logs?
      • I am an Independent Researcher, how do I sign up?
      • How do I locate the date a submission is made public?
      • I am a reviewer but I can't access my assigned submissions, what do I do?
      • Reviewers for my venue cannot see their assigned submissions, what should I do?
      • I am a reviewer and I don't have papers for Expertise Selection, what do I do?
      • How do I upload a publication with a license that is not listed?
      • I didn't receive a password reset email, what do I do?
      • How do I add/change an author of my submission after the deadline?
      • How do I find a venue id?
      • Why can't I update my DBLP link?
    • Using the API
      • Installing and Instantiating the Python client
      • Groups
    • Hosting a venue on OpenReview
      • Creating your Venue Instance
      • Navigating your Venue Pages
      • Customizing your submission form
      • Enabling Supplementary Material Upload
      • Changing your submission deadline
      • Enabling an Abstract Registration Deadline
    • Creating an OpenReview Profile
      • Signing up for OpenReview
      • Resending an activation link
      • Expediting Profile Activation
      • Add or remove a name from your profile
      • Add or remove an email address from your profile
      • Finding your profile ID
      • Entering Institutional Data
      • Importing papers from DBLP
      • Manually adding a publication to your profile
      • Finding and adding a Semantic Scholar URL to your profile
      • Finding and adding your ACL Anthology URL to your profile
      • Merging Profiles
    • Customizing Forms
    • Using the New Forum Page
    • Live Chat on the Forum Page
  • Workflows
    • Example Workflow
    • ARR Commitment Venues
    • Exercises for workflow chairs
      • Prerequisites
      • Exercise: Posting LLM generated reviews
  • How-To Guides
    • Modifying Venue Homepages
      • How to customize your venue homepage
      • How to modify the homepage layout to show decision tabs
    • Managing Groups
      • How to Recruit and Remind Recruited Reviewers
      • How to have multiple Reviewer or Area Chair groups
      • How to Add and Remove Members from a Group
      • Publication Chairs
      • How to Copy Members from One Group to Another
    • Workflow
      • How to Programmatically Post Support Request Form
      • How to test your venue workflow
      • How to Post a Test Submission
      • How to support different tracks for a venue
      • How to Make Submissions Available Before the Submission Deadline
      • How to Change the Expiration Date of the Submission Invitation
      • Desk Reject Submissions that are Missing PDFs
      • How to begin the Review Stage while Submissions are Open
      • How to Change Who can Access Submissions After the Deadline
      • How to Enable Commenting on Submissions
      • How to Set a Custom Deadline for Withdrawals
      • How to Enable an Ethics Review Stage
      • How to Hide Submission Fields from Reviewers
      • How to modify the Review, Meta Review, and Decision Forms
      • How to release reviews
      • How to Enable the Rebuttal Period
      • How to Undo a Paper Withdrawal
      • How to enable Camera Ready Revision Upload for accepted papers
      • How to make papers public after decisions are made
      • How to enable bidding for Senior Area Chair Assignment
      • How to release the identities of authors of accepted papers only
      • How to enable the Review Revision Stage
    • Paper Matching and Assignment
      • How to Compute Conflicts Between Users
      • How to Post a Custom Conflict
      • How to create your own Conflict Policy
      • How to Bid on Submissions
      • How to add/remove bids programmatically
      • How to do manual assignments
      • How to do automatic assignments
        • How to setup paper matching by calculating affinity scores and conflicts
        • How to run a paper matching
        • How to modify the proposed assignments
        • How to deploy the proposed assignments
        • How to modify assignments after deployment
      • How to enable Reviewer Reassignment for Area Chairs
      • How to Sync Manual and Automatic Assignments
      • How to Compute Affinity Scores
      • How to Undo Deployed Assignments
      • How to Modify Reviewer Assignments as an Area Chair
      • How to Get all Assignments for a User
      • How to Update Custom Max Papers for Reviewers or ACs
      • How to Make Assignments using Subject Areas
    • Communication
      • How to send messages through the UI
      • How to customize emails sent through OpenReview
      • How to send messages with the python client
      • How to Send Decision Notifications Using the UI
      • How to view messages sent through OpenReview
      • How to email the authors of accepted submissions
      • How to get email adresses
    • Submissions, comments, reviews, and decisions
      • How to add formatting to reviews or comments
      • How to submit a Review Revision
      • How to add formulas or use mathematical notation
      • How to edit a submission after the deadline - Authors
      • How to upload paper decisions in bulk
      • How to hide/reveal fields
      • Update camera-ready PDFs after the deadline expires
    • Data Retrieval and Modification
      • How to check the API version of a venue
      • How to view Camera-Ready Revisions
      • How to Export all Submission Attachments
      • How to loop through Accepted Papers and print the Authors and their Affiliations
      • How to add/remove fields from a submission
      • How to manually change the readers of a note
      • How to post/delete an Official Review using Python
      • How to Get Profiles and Their Relations
      • How to Get All the Reviews that I have written and their Corresponding Submissions
      • How to Get All Registration Notes
      • How to Get All Submissions
      • How to Get All Reviews
      • How to Export All Reviews into a CSV
      • How to get all Rebuttals
      • How to Get All Official Comments
      • How to Get All MetaReviews
      • How to Get All Decisions
      • How to Get All Venues
      • How to Retrieve Data for ACM Proceedings
      • How to Get Reviewer Ratings
  • Reference
    • API V1
      • OpenAPI definition
      • Entities
        • Edge
          • Fields
        • Note
          • Fields
        • Invitation
    • API V2
      • OpenAPI definition
      • Entities
        • Edge
          • Fields
        • Group
          • Fields
        • Note
          • Fields
        • Invitation
          • Types and Structure
          • Fields
          • Specifiers
          • Dollar Sign Notation
        • Edit
          • Fields
          • Inference
    • Stages
      • Revision
      • Registration Stage
      • Bid Stage
      • Review Stage
      • Rebuttal Stage
      • Meta Review Stage
      • Decision Stage
      • Comment Stage
      • Submission Revision Stage
      • Post Submission Stage
      • Post Decision Stage
      • Ethics Review Stage
    • Default Forms
      • Default Submission Form
      • Default Registration Form
      • Default Comment Form
      • Default Review Form
      • Default Rebuttal Form
      • Default Meta Review Form
      • Default Decision Form
      • Default Decision Notification
      • Default Ethics Review Form
    • OpenReview TeX
      • Common Issues with LaTeX Code Display
      • OpenReview TeX support
    • Mental Model on Blind Submissions and Revisions
Powered by GitBook
On this page

Was this helpful?

Export as PDF
  1. Reference
  2. Stages

Meta Review Stage

PreviousRebuttal StageNextDecision Stage

Last updated 1 year ago

Was this helpful?

What it Does

The Meta Review Stage creates paper groups and . It should be used to edit the Meta Review form. Use of the Meta Review Stage will overwrite any changes made to the Meta Review Invitations through the Invitation Editor. It also sets the visibility of all existing and future meta reviews.

When to Use it

For API 1 venues, the Meta Review Stage should not be run until after the submission deadline, except in the case of public, single blind venues. They can begin the Meta Review Stage before the submission deadline if they first run 'Post Submission Stage' to create paper groups.

For API 2 venues, you can run the Meta Review Stage to configure the settings and the form, and once the start date is reached the invitation will become active.

Skip this if your venue does not have Area Chairs.

Options

Meta Review Start Date
  • Enter a time and date you want the Meta Review period to begin in GMT using the following format: YYYY/MM/DD HH:MM (e.g. 2019/01/31 23:59)

  • Optional

  • Defaults to now

Meta Review Deadline
  • This is the official, soft deadline Area Chairs will see.

  • Enter a time and date in GMT using the following format: YYYY/MM/DD HH:MM (e.g. 2019/01/31 23:59)

  • Optional

Meta Review Expiration Date
  • After this date, no more meta reviews can be submitted. This is the hard deadline area chairs will not be able to see.

  • Enter a time and date in GMT using the following format: YYYY/MM/DD HH:MM (e.g. 2019/01/31 23:59)

  • Optional

  • Default is 30 minutes after the meta review deadline

Make Meta Reviews Public (required)
  • This setting determines whether or not meta reviews are public the moment they are posted.

  • Default is "No, meta reviews should NOT be revealed publicly when they are posted"

Release Meta Reviews To Authors (required)
  • This setting determines whether or not meta reviews are visible to authors the moment they are posted.

  • Default is "No, meta reviews should NOT be revealed when they are posted to the paper's authors"

Release Meta Reviews To Reviewers (required)
  • This setting determines whether or not meta reviews are visible to reviewers the moment they are posted.

  • Default is "Meta review should not be revealed to any reviewer"

Additional Meta Review Form Options
  • This is where you can configure additional options in the meta review form.

  • Use lowercase for the field names and underscores to represent spaces. The UI will auto-format the names, for example: supplementary_material -> Supplementary Material.

  • Valid JSON is expected.

  • Optional

Remove Meta Review Form Options
  • Removes fields from the Default Meta Review form. Expects a comma separated list of field names in lowercase.

  • Optional

The .

meta review invitations
Default Meta Review Form